← Research using Delve

PLoS ONE · March 2026

Stakeholder priorities and conceptualization of One Health: Insights from fuzzy cognitive mapping and grounded theory

Evan F. Griffith, Angela Opondoh, Catherine Kaluwa, Erenius Lochede Nakadio (20874083), Kipkorir Rotich, Job Ronoh Kipkemoi, Jonah Levin, Jacob Mutua, Siobhan M. Mor, Janetrix Hellen Amuguni

Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine, Tufts University

Grounded theoryOther Public health

How they used Delve

Researchers at Tufts University's Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine, with the University of Nairobi and Turkana County's One Health Unit, used Delve to analyse transcripts of 26 fuzzy cognitive mapping sessions with pastoralist communities, frontline workers and government stakeholders in Turkana County, Kenya, coding them with Straussian grounded theory; three researchers coded and cross-checked their coding decisions.

“Mapping session transcripts were uploaded to Delve for qualitative analysis (www.delvetool.com). [...] To enhance rigor, coding was conducted by three researchers, with regular cross-checking of coding decisions and emerging categories.”

Field
One Health / stakeholder priorities in pastoralist settings
Data
Transcripts of 26 fuzzy cognitive mapping sessions in Turkana County, Kenya: 15 community group sessions (8 men's, 7 women's), 2 mixed-gender sessions with community frontline workers, and 8 individual sessions with administration, health and veterinary stakeholders
Approach
Fuzzy cognitive mapping in group and individual sessions with network analysis of the maps; session transcripts analysed with Straussian grounded theory (open and axial coding) using the Corbin and Strauss paradigm of conditions, action-interactions and consequences, coded iteratively with memo-writing
Data types
Focus groups, Interviews

Abstract

One Health (OH) has gained global recognition as a framework and practice for addressing interconnected health and sustainability challenges, such as emerging infectious diseases, food insecurity and climate change. Yet its operationalization remains limited, in part due to persistent differences in how OH is conceptualized across sectors and knowledge systems, including Indigenous knowledge holders and environmental actors. To address these gaps, we applied a mixed methods approach that combined fuzzy cognitive mapping (FCM) with grounded theory (GT) to examine stakeholder priorities and conceptualization of OH in Turkana County, Kenya. Thirty-six fuzzy cognitive maps were co-developed with community members, frontline workers, health, veterinary, and NGO stakeholders, then aggregated by group and analyzed using network metrics including normalized degree centrality and Jaccard similarity. Results revealed areas of alignment and convergence in OH conceptualization and perspective. Conceptually, the environment group map was the most distinct, while the health and NGO maps were the most similar. Environmental actors emphasized human-driven degradation, while community members described a pluralistic health system and the importance of wild foods, both absent from other group narratives. Shared priorities such as human and livestock health, nutrition, and water resources represent potential entry points for cross-sectoral integration. These findings demonstrate that barriers to OH operationalization are not only structural, but also shaped by differences in knowledge, experience, and problem framing across sectors and society within the socioecological system. Embedding ecosystem services, biodiversity, and traditional knowledge at the core of OH can enhance inclusivity and contextual relevance. Our integrated FCM-GT approach offers a transferable framework for participatory systems research, providing actionable insights for more inclusive and ecologically grounded OH implementation.

Citation

Evan F. Griffith, Angela Opondoh, Catherine Kaluwa, Erenius Lochede Nakadio (20874083), Kipkorir Rotich, Job Ronoh Kipkemoi, Jonah Levin, Jacob Mutua, Siobhan M. Mor, Janetrix Hellen Amuguni (2026). Stakeholder priorities and conceptualization of One Health: Insights from fuzzy cognitive mapping and grounded theory. PLoS ONE. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0338167

Resources

Start your 14 day free trial of Delve