Progress, challenges, and lessons for climate resilient and low carbon health systems in Latin America and the Caribbean: an exploratory mixed-methods study
Universidad Peruana Cayetano Heredia, with PAHO/WHO, the World Bank and the Inter-American Development Bank
How they used Delve
Researchers at Universidad Peruana Cayetano Heredia, working with PAHO/WHO, the World Bank and the Inter-American Development Bank, used Delve for coding, theme management and an audit trail of analytical decisions across interviews with health ministry focal points in Argentina, Chile, Jamaica and Peru on building climate-resilient, low-carbon health systems.
“The qualitative analysis software Delve (https://delvetool.com) was used for coding, theme management, and maintaining an audit trail of analytical decisions. Using consensus coding and individual memos, two researchers (YPS, CLl) independently check the audio and read and analysed the scripts, identifying key information respective to the guiding questions (deductive coding) and emerging codes regarding challenges, enablers, and lessons learned throughout different processes of building CRLC-HS (inductive coding).”
- Field
- Climate change and health systems / health policy
- Data
- Four one-hour online semi-structured interviews with Ministry of Health and PAHO country focal points in Argentina, Chile, Jamaica and Peru — each with three to four key informants — conducted in English or Spanish between March and August 2025, alongside country-level data from the PAHO 2021/2022 and 2023/2024 Climate Change and Health surveys covering 33 LAC countries
- Approach
- Explanatory sequential mixed methods: descriptive analysis of two PAHO Climate Change and Health surveys, then semi-structured interviews analysed by consensus coding — deductive coding against the guiding questions plus inductive coding of emerging challenges, enablers and lessons — with two independent coders, a third researcher joining to cluster codes into themes, discrepancies resolved by discussion rather than an inter-rater coefficient, and respondent validation with all participants
- Data types
- Interviews, Open-ended survey responses
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To assess progress, challenges, and enabling factors for building climate-resilient and low-carbon health systems across Latin America and the Caribbean, a region facing accelerating climate-sensitive health burdens amidst persistent health system fragilities. METHODS: We conducted an explanatory, sequential, mixed-methods study integrating quantitative analysis of the Pan American Health Organisation Climate Change and Health surveys from 2021/2022 (n = 24 countries) and 2023/2024 (n = 27 countries) with semi-structured interviews involving four countries demonstrating progress (Argentina, Chile, Jamaica, Peru). Quantitative data were analysed descriptively across three sub-regions (Caribbean, Central America, South America). Qualitative data underwent two-stage coding (deductive and inductive) with three-researcher consensus to identify barriers, enablers, and lessons learned. RESULTS: By 2023/2024, 93% of countries had designated climate-health focal points (71% in 2021/2022). However, implementation gaps persist: less than 50% of countries had integrated climate change into national health reports; 22%-40% developed national climate-health strategies; and vulnerability assessments rarely informed policy. Access to international climate finance remained inequitable. Whilst 60%-74% developed disaster preparedness plans, only 30%-44% implemented public health communication campaigns. Training focused on environmental health personnel, with doctors, nurses, and planning staff minimally engaged. Qualitative analysis revealed interconnected barriers: climate change perceived as distant rather than urgent, competing priorities overwhelming decision-makers, institutional silos, and misalignment between available training and local needs. Key enablers included linking climate action to established health priorities, institutionalising responsibilities through formal mechanisms, multi-stakeholder engagement, and committed individuals with diplomatic skills navigating cross-sectoral dynamics. CONCLUSION: Latin America and the Caribbean countries are establishing foundations for climate-resilient and low-carbon health systems, but translating governance progress into sustained implementation requires addressing systemic barriers through institutionalisation beyond political cycles, tailored capacity building, and innovative financing mechanisms. These findings inform guidance for health systems strengthening amidst accelerating climate change.
Citation
Yasna Palmeiro-Silva, Camila Llerena-Cayo, Sebastian Bauhoff, Kristie L. Ebi, Catharina Giudice, Cristián Herrera, Jeremy Hess, Zuhelen Padilla, Karen Polson, Zoila Vela-Clavo, Daniel Forsin Buss, Stella M. Hartinger (2026). Progress, challenges, and lessons for climate resilient and low carbon health systems in Latin America and the Caribbean: an exploratory mixed-methods study. Revista de Saúde Pública. https://doi.org/10.11606/s1518-8787.2026060007430