← Research using Delve

bioRxiv · September 2023

PubNavigator as an undergraduate teaching tool

Rosario A. Marroquín-Flores, Maverick A. Campbell, Stephanie Grimes, Lisa B. Limeri

Texas Tech University

Thematic analysisContent analysis Education

How they used Delve

A biology education research team at Texas Tech University used Delve to code undergraduate discussion forum responses across deductive and inductive phases, with three researchers coding each section independently and meeting to consensus, to test whether the PubNavigator platform promotes scientific reasoning.

“All qualitative data were analyzed using Delve Coding Software (https://delvetool.com/).”

Field
Biology education / science reasoning and reading engagement in undergraduates
Data
Student responses to an assignment discussing PubNavigator articles in an asynchronous online discussion forum in an introductory biology course, across cohorts of roughly 21-23 students
Approach
Thematic analysis guided by the Evidence-Based Reasoning Framework, run in phases: a deductive phase evaluating students' use of evidence in scientific reasoning, then an inductive phase characterising reading engagement in which codes were created, combined and deleted to fit the research question. In every phase three team members coded each section individually and then met to reach consensus; when group discussion changed the codebook or coding approach, all previously coded data was revisited and recoded under the new scheme
Data types
Documents

Abstract

Abstract The ability to use data and evidence as the basis for scientific reasoning is a critical skill that undergraduate students must learn to successfully transition into science careers. There is a need for pedagogical tools that promote the development of science process skills and reduce barriers to implementation in the classroom. PubNavigator ( www.pubnavigator.com ) is a science communication platform that shares the findings of primary literature using accessible language and features biographical information about the authors. This research assesses the utility of PubNavigator as an undergraduate teaching resource. We analyzed responses to an assignment prompting discussion of PubNavigator articles in an asynchronous online discussion forum in an introductory biology course. We conducted thematic analysis guided by the evidence-based reasoning framework to identify evidence of science reasoning and interactive enagement. We found evidence that the PubNavigator assignment elicited engagement in scientific reasoning. Students who demonstrated higher levels of engagement with the assignment also demonstrated higher levels of science reasoning in their discussion of the articles. Our findings support PubNavigator as an undergraduate teaching tool that can be used to promote science reasoning and engagement in introductory biology. We provide recommendations for implementation to instructors interested in integrating PubNavigator activities into their courses.

Citation

Rosario A. Marroquín-Flores, Maverick A. Campbell, Stephanie Grimes, Lisa B. Limeri (2023). PubNavigator as an undergraduate teaching tool. bioRxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/2023.09.18.558293

Resources

Start your 14 day free trial of Delve